Hall of Famers such as Jerry West, Kareem Abdul-Jabbar and Magic Johnson have taken issue with the over-the-top portrayals. Jerry West feels that the show’s representation of him was a “baseless and malicious assault.” Not to be outdone, Kareem Abdul-Jabbar wrote on his blog that Winning Time is “deliberately dishonest.”
Additionally, Norm Nixon shed light on one of the prevalent storylines, his friction with rookie Magic Johnson. On fellow Legend Cedric Maxwell’s podcast, he noted that the show overstated his competition with Johnson over playing time at the point guard slot. Winning Time consistently showed Nixon hazing Johnson about his “country” upbringing, although according to Nixon himself, that’s not how events unfolded.
“Number one, I’m from Macon, Georgia, man. I’m from the country. And I wore my country-ness with pride … So number one, that kind of stuff would never happen,” Nixon declared.
However, not every Legend is upset. Spencer Haywood stated he felt the show was “very accurate” and has spurred fans and media to reach out and discuss his personal story.
“I was sick. I was crying. I couldn’t control my emotions watching the show,” Haywood noted in a recent interview.
He even joined the NBRPA’s “Legends Lounge w/ Trill Withers” podcast and mentioned his approval of the interpretation of Kareem Abdul-Jabbar and the impact their friendship has had on his life.
During the 2022 NBA All-Star Weekend in February, NBA Legend and NBRPA Cleveland Chapter President Jim Chones told us that he very much enjoyed working on the production of Winning Time while praising actor Newton Mayenge’s portrayal of him.
In the spring, HBO announced that the second season of Winning Time would be coming soon. The show's sophomore season could potentially lead viewers into the 1980-81 NBA season, where an injured Magic was limited to 37 games and the Lakers were ousted from the playoffs in the first round by Moses Malone and the Houston Rockets.
What remains to be seen is if the series will eventually dive into the 1983-84 season, when the Boston Celtics and Los Angeles met in the NBA Finals and rekindled a rivalry that embodied the NBA and captured the world’s attention.
What we do know is that a follow-up season will continue to spark more conversation around one of the most magnificent times in basketball lore. More importantly, the series will continue to show the impact and power our Legends and their stories have on the collective imagination.